Dumbledore would win pretty much because gandalf would be surprised by this unknown magic. Dumbledore if a ing pussy bitch who got disarmed by a teenager and killed by an emo hippie got who loved a kids mom and got pantsed in school daily. The full strength of the maia is unleashed, in order to defeat this agent of the enemy, gandalf finds it nessicery to break his promise to his creators and masters and push himself beyond his limited. Its a great way of getting a general idea for specific things as well as collating other primary or secondary sources. Dumbledore vs gandalf the lord of the rings minecraft mod wiki fandom. Gandalf the white well he survived death beating the one thing that dumbledoor spent most of his life trying to get and failing to do so. He only died to snape cuz they were splitting the pot and didnt want to try. In the past decade, the silver screen has brought some of the most epic wizards to life for millions of people throughout the world. Heck, he can probably even take on merlin, although i doubt he could win against a half. But its pretty obvious from the books that gandalf has a lot more power than he ever shows.
He is known to possess supernatural powers and had many clashes with other characters. But who would win in a throwdown between these two juggernauts. With the extra power of the ring, gandalf manages to escape middle earth, and get to narnia, and sets up shop in the northern part of narnia. Dumbledore vs gandalf the lord of the rings minecraft. Many other people have had this same question and many discussions have been conducted online. Gandalf explodes and is hurled back, but teleports quickly and comes behind dumbledore and punches him in the back. One of his main goals in life is to become a published author. Book or movie, voldemort is a minor league prospect compared to the dark. Book gandalf was more powerful than his movie version iirc. Ive never had the chance to read the lord of the rings books but ive seen the first movie. Also, given gandalf is literally an immortal being, i think dumbledore might be able to beat gandalf, but not for any significant length of time, so overall i think gandalf would win. Who would win, gandalf lord of the rings vs aslan the.
Dumbledore may have had more powerful magic, but the magic in the hp universe is obviously much less spiritual and a lot more physical. Gandalf the grey gandalf the white so yeah dumbledoor could beat gandalf if and only if gandalf stays dead the first time. Gandalf is more about the internal power that comes with being a millenia old and wise demigodly being. Who would win in a battle between dumbledore and gandalf. Gandalf took a fireball to the face from sauroman and it did jack because gandalf has one of them super powerful magic rings that make the. In one fandom you have dumbledore, also known as the greatest wizard who ever lived, according to j. I think if you did another poll you would find the people who said voldemort and dumbledore would win are in their teens, and the grown ups would pick gandalf and sauron. After 2000 years he wouldnt expect something unknown to crop up.
In another fandom you have gandalf, an incredibly powerful wizard in the. In my view dumbledore has a bigger arsenal of magic so dumbledore. Accio his staff transfigure the ground beneath gandalf to trap him. Gandalf vs dumbledore would just come down to whether or not gandalf would be able to deal with the massive, massive disapparation camping basically a teleport. Dumbledore and gandalf pull out their swords and engage in a sword duel, causing clink noises. Gandalf can use the same level of power he used against the balrog and dumbledore can use any spell except the unforgivable curses. George rr martin says gandalf would kick dumbledores ass in a fight. If dumbledore does any of a large number of things that could theoretically ruin gandalf s day, he pretty much wins. Gandalf then nudges dumbledore back, causing him to flail back. At one time or another, youve felt confused and lost, struggling through lifes labyrinth of snares and pitfalls. Percy jackson, you can probably trust dumbledore to win if he subbed for the boy who lived. So i mean, on paper, gandalf should win because hes basically an angel, but dumbledore demonstrated better feats, especially if were going with movies alone, imo. But he cant do a fraction of the things that dumbledore can. Who would win in a fight between dumbledore and gandalf.
Dumbledore has the ability to more magic, because magic is more common in his universe, however i think gandalfs magic may be a bit more raw and powerful. Is it true that gandalf the grey from the books was a far more free spirited. Gandalf versus dumbledore whos the ultimate wizard. So, essentially, this is a matter of who hits first. I think ganondorf would run a train on both of them, though. Or the killing curse, which we have no reason to believe wouldnt work on gandalf, who has died before, if youll recall. I dont understand why he gets praised such a mature writer, seriously. Sure, merlin and dumbledore could cast spells and enchantments, but gandalf s power was so immense, it could literally break the world.
Around 100 years old, considered the greatest wizard of. Gandalf would win, not only can he use magic but also weapons so dumbledore is going down. Hes got trump cards that gandalf has no answer to, like transfiguration. This discussion was going on for ages and it will end now once and for all. Epic rap battles of history gandalf vs dumbledore lyrics. Albus dumbledore is a character in the popular movie series, harry potter. I propose that you both endeavour to draft a script that which addresses the musing offered up by george, on the unique powers displayed by gandalf vs those manifest by dumbledore. And gandalf, the great wizard of the lord of the rings, has long been almost as. Dumbledore is from harry potter and gandalf is from the lord of the rings. If he jumped into the lotr universe, he would probably be. Gandalf might disagree, judging by his drab grey cloak and hat. It turns out the red book was fictiona whitewash of the real truth. Gandalf vs dumbledore comments showing 150 of 141 141 new.
Dumbledore has access to a vast array of spells and magical devices that do all kinds of useful things. Gandalf in takes dragons and giant fire beasts and doesnt afraid of anything. They are both giants in the world of literature, and the. If there was a 1on1 battle between voldemort and dumbledore, who would win. The old and wise, yet very powerful wizard rivalry comes to an astonishing end today. Discussion for the sake of the discussion, both would be at the best time in their lifes, and. Tolkien, the author of the hobbit and the lord of the rings. Martin revealed who he thinks would win in a fight between two of the most iconic wizards in the world. White, who calls him merlyn as the overall winner, depending on whether we were talking about gandalf the grey, or his. Dumbledore defeated the dark wizard grindelwald and is known for discovering the 12 uses of dragons blood. Who would win in a fight gandalf vs dumbledore the student room. Gandalf cant do the same because dumbledore doesnt need a wand to cast.
Dumbledore defeated the dark wizard grindelwald and is known for discovering the. Dumbledore completely manipluates everyone around him to do his work because he cant do it himself. If we go by what is actually written, dumbledore would have the. Sauron would win, hands down as gandalf would also emerge victorious. We saw gandalf do a limited number of things, although some were quite dramatic.
So prepare your forbidden books and steadily growing beards, magic fans, as we. Of course, as we see in the books, gandalf i think has restrictions on what magic he can perform, while dumbledore has nothing but his own morals to restrict him. If dumbledore does any of a large number of things that could theoretically ruin gandalfs day, he. Add to my favorites report this debate share with my friends. And in his lore gandalf is godlike, but the only chance hed have against ligtsabers and force lightning is if he came back from the dead again. If dumbledore and gandalf had a fight, who would win. Gandalf vs dumbledore death battle fanon wiki fandom. You realize, only versions that would win against dumbledore or voldemort. George rr martin says gandalf would kick dumbledore s ass in a fight.
Youve been searching for that lost part of your soul, that piece of knowledge like an everelusive unicorn waiting to be found. If these two characters decide to fight, who do you think would win. Want great book recommendations in your inbox every week. As gandalf the grey he would not have been, dumbledore would clearly have been the winner against gandalf the grey. Assume they are both in their prime and gandalf s immortality doesnt matter because it only depends on who would win the fight regardless of if gandalf would be reborn. If gandalf went with the sword dumbledore would win because he can block physical attacks with his. In this episode of variant, the most powerful wizard in the wizarding world faces off against the most powerful wizard from middle earth its dumbledore vs gandalf. I mean of course gandalf is more powerful, but has nothing to do with him coming back. National treasures, sir ian mckellen and sir michael gambon are the faces of two of the most famous wizards in literary history. At the center of netflixs the order is a struggle between two prominent, magical groups. He still probably wins though, because hes got access to so many more options than gandalf. If gandalf burminates dumbledore s wand which he can pretty much do with a handwave, he pretty much wins. He picked either gandalf or merlin of the once and future king by t.
While i was upset reading the books when dumbledore died, he turns out to be pretty manipulative, and while the same could be said of gandalf manipulating bilbo to leave the. In reality, frodo actually did persuade gandalf to accept the one ring, which slowly turned gandalf evil. At the red carpet premiere of tolkien the biopic based on lord of the rings author j. Meanwhile good old dumbledore farts magic rainbows every time he blinks. Gandalf the grey would win, although dumbledore might have a couple of tricks up his sleeve which would throw gandalf for a loop. Whether or not they have actually read harry potter or the lord of the rings, there cant be many people who can claim ignorance as to. After defeating the balrog, gandalfs earthly body perishes and his soul flees back to valinor. Now gandalf the white is a different story entirely. About gandalf vs dumbledore an installment in the epic rap battles of history series, a comedy series on youtube by nicepeter and epiclloyd that features two historical or. According to variety, star lily collins who plays tolkiens wife edith bratt in the film revealed her. The greater wizard, and the wiser wizard cannot be judged, they are both equal. Discover unique things to do, places to eat, and sights to see in the best destinations around the world with bring me. The harry potter and lord of the rings franchises are often compared to one another.
Like someone said dumbledore would turn his saber into a snake and use the killing curse. And the idea of sacrificing himself for the cause would not have been nessecary had he been a strong a wizard as gandalf. Nah, you cant compare dumbledore s magic vs gandalf s magic. Gandalf and dumbledore may have legions of fans behind them, but the time has come to. In an interview with ian mckellen about his role as king lear he touches on the role of dumbledore and his portrayal of gandalf from the lord of the. Gandalf the white on the other hand is a character in the lord of the rings who is also a wizard. If gandalf burminates dumbledores wand which he can pretty much do with a handwave, he pretty much wins. Who would win in a fight between gandalf and harry potter. The hardest game of who would win in a fight youll ever. Wizards arent a common thing in gandalfs world, but gandalf the white, vs albus dumbledore would not be an easily interpretation of a fight. This debate could go on for many pages and fill a book with an endless quirrel see what i did there. Gandalf not only has his staff, but he has a powerful sword and an elven ring of fate. In another fandom you have gandalf, an incredibly powerful wizard in the world of j. Though dumbledore flicks his wand like no other, it would take an awful case of arthritis to put down the white wizard holding the staff.
1397 414 1289 1390 127 1367 1285 701 1355 639 594 498 1183 3 1039 1242 1523 912 521 766 1155 1047 922 150 466 55 1076 431 1380 5 1252 666 1309 828 656 563 551 785